Matt and Cat\'s Isle of Wight Eating Out Guide
Shanklin is a town of two halves; the touristy Old Village with its picture-postcard thatches and tea shoppes and the more utilitarian Regent Street/High...

Shanklin is a town of two halves; the touristy Old Village with its picture-postcard thatches and tea shoppes and the more utilitarian Regent Street/High Street conglomeration.

Surf 'n' turf

On the northern approaches there are a few hotels and the occasional peripheral eatery and it was at this outer edge that Matt and Cat found themselves one Saturday tea time.

Banging on the locked door of Saffrons to no avail, Matt and Cat loped up the road to the Plough and Barleycorn, tempted by its proclamations of ‘great food’ and, because they had a nipper in tow – junior reviewer Bill – the promise of ‘family dining’. Stepping up to the entrance, Cat was again was faced with a locked door. Determined to eat something somewhere, she and the two chaps tried the side entrance with more success. At the bar a cheery fellow greeted the trio and advised them that food was, indeed, available. Hopefully they would have success this time…

The three of them had built up quite an appetite fossil hunting at the foot of Culver and Redcliff. Matt had taken on the role of Health and Safety monitor, shooing his charges away from the cliff’s base as tiny pebbles trickled down its sheer face, dislodged by birds. Amongst the smooth stones and crumbling bits of chalk, Cat had found a giant ammonite and Bill had carried this vast fossil back to Yaverland, alternating arms as he went. After this productive adventure they all deserved a hearty tea.

chicken and mushroom pie and chips

Having never been in the Plough and Barleycorn before its new owners took charge, it is not possible for Matt and Cat to say how it has changed, if at all. The building looked quite old from the outside and there were a few hints to Shanklin’s past inside, including a nice selection of postcards but otherwise it was a little bland, albeit new and clean, looking like it had just been refurbished. For those who enjoy family dining there were identified areas in the pub specifically for families and also, for the less kiddie-inclined, child-free zones. Matt and Cat didn’t notice this segregation until they had sat with teenager Bill in the adult-only area. However, he promised not to yell, throw food or run screaming around the other diners so they stayed put without any hard stares.

Matt & Cat’s bill
Steak & ale pie £4.95
Chicken & mushroom pie £4.95
Surf & turf £9.95
Total: £20.85

The Plough and Barleycorn has a small menu with some pub grub standards: pie and chips, various steaks, lasagne and a couple of curries. Cat chose chicken and mushroom pie and chips, Matt ordered surf and turf and Bill requested steak and ale pie and chips. Cat was advised of a twenty minute wait as she ordered the food but they were in no hurry. Somehow, a wait seems so much more acceptable when you’ve been warned about it.

They sat and listened to the piped muzak and the squealing and banging from the family room. They chatted about the geology of the Isle of Wight and the concept of the ‘sleepover’, a phenomenon not invented when Cat was a a lass. Bill talked of high scores. Normally at this point a bit of eavesdropping provides material for M & C to insert into reviews, but not this time. The five occupants at the other table stared into space; they must have had a busy day.

The Plough and Barleycorn is making a stab at the family pub market, and this is quite courageous given that it has hardly any car park and requires diners to walk 100 metres or so to get to the front door – anathema to many of today’s car-bound families. It would be good for it to succeed, although it’s a bit early to say if it will. Look out for a drift downmarket if it starts turning into a sports bar or vertical-drinking establishment in the off-season – but at present there is little sign of either.

The food arrived. The pies were both served with chips and mixed vegetables. Cat’s chicken and mushroom pie had a nice home-made look about it and was really chock full o’ meat. The mushrooms, too, were clearly identifiable, not just a mushy gesture. It tasted good too. The chips were nice and chunky and, because the dish was served with gravy there was no need for Cat’s favoured twin chip lubricants of ketchup and mayonnaise.

Bill reported similarly satisfactory pie-pleasure on the steak-and-ale front, and his pie came with some decent chunks of meat in it and plenty of gravy. Matt’s surf and turf was a meal with two aspects, as the name might suggest. Five little breaded scampi fragments just about made up the surf contingent, but were very much outshone by an excellent bit of rump steak, although it wasn’t quite as rare as requested.

Plough and Barleycorn

All meals were eaten with pleasure: this was a decent, pub feed. The Plough and Barleycorn was unremarkable, but satisfactory. The basic pie meals were very good value, and this is the area where the Plough and Barleycorn will probably always do well. The footsore geologists were soon refreshed and ready to set off for more adventures.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • graham

    6th January 2013 #1 Author

    We had our works christmas meal at the Plough and Barleycorn,and the whole event was just superb.
    On booking the event we asked for changes to be made to the christmas menu, and this was done without any hesitation.
    On the evening itself the hosts could not have been any more atentive.The whole event was just superb in everyway.
    I would reccomend the plough & b to everyone, without any hesitation.
    I’ve been back since, and it gets better and better.
    Thanks Sharon & Les!

    Reply

  • steve collins

    27th February 2012 #2 Author

    Went there 2 weeks ago and ordered a cheeseburger and my son ordered a lasagne, took 35minutes for food to arrive. bun was burnt, burger overcooked ,hardly any cheese, best part of the meal was the chops, the coleslaw had big pieces of cabbage. My son lasagne was cold in the middle, tiny portion for the price. will not be coming back or be recommending to anyone.
    The lady behind the bar was very loud and not very friendly, very disappointed…

    Steve

    Reply

  • Colin

    7th January 2012 #3 Author

    We’ve been to the Plough twice in the past week, the place has recently changed hands and the emphasis seems to be very much on the food. We’ve had (in no particular order): Burger, scampi, gammon and you’ve guessed it…. Chips. Also the spicy beef stir fry, sausage and mash….. And chicken burger and chips!

    Special mention must go to the stir-fry and chicken burger, top quality.

    Without fail the meals have been spot on, all the staff seem really friendly and the food well portioned. It isn’t the most expansive or elaborate menu but it is honest pub grub, served with a smile and has been very good indeed.

    I haven’t tried the desserts (indulged in a Guinness instead) but wifey and Mother in law seemed very happy with theirs and our daughter with her ice-cream.

    I would recommend giving it another go, and there is a 20% off voucher in the Beacon. The pub does welcome families.

    It is a tough time of year to kick off a new venture but I think it would be good to see the Plough finally settle and hopefully thrive under new ownership so I would recommend giving the place a try!

    Reply

  • ACW

    1st September 2010 #4 Author

    This hostelry has had a very successful summer – a credit to the new owners who took over in April. Good wholesome food served all day at now reasonable prices. Refer to the comments on Trip Advisor for further information.

    Reply

  • Local Lass

    21st April 2010 #5 Author

    The Plough actually changed hands again very recently – just before Easter I think…

    Reply

  • Dee Bee

    20th April 2010 #6 Author

    The Plough and Barleycorn website linked to from the review doesn’t seem to tell you much other than the site is soon coming down “legal action against the new owners” and lots of sections telling you “no comment”

    Matt and Cat respond: Thanks for your comment, Dee Bee. We were aware that there wasn’t much information on the site when we wrote the review. The link is now removed, as it’s clearly not very useful.

    Reply