Archive review: Mamma Mia, Shanklin
This is an archive review. Mamma Mia has now closed this restaurant and opened another. This review and the comments on it refer to the former venue.
Some considerable time ago, Cat was a regular patron of Pavarotti's Restaurant in Shanklin. Its Italian staff were very welcoming, the authentic Mediterranean food was excellent and flavoursome and the venue was in the style of La Scala - raffia-wrapped wine bottles and piped opera.
The proprietor of Pavarotti's opened a second eatery in Shanklin, the disappointingly short-lived Carrera's (now Chubby's Chunky Chip Shop) on Regent Street; a good spot for a lunchtime gossip over a thin pizza.
Ever-watchful of the goings-on in the Isle of Wight's restaurant world, Matt and Cat noticed the arrival of a new Italian restaurant in Shanklin and, as they had cause to be in that seaside town one night, decided to pay it a visit.
Review continues:
Mamma Mia occupies a prominent position on the corner of Orchardleigh Road and the High Street, perfect for reeling in passing holiday trade. Cryptically, they have been for some time advertising themselves with a rather feeble tangled banner (see picture) which makes identifying the place a little tricky. Undeterred, Matt and Cat were able to take a chance on a coveted window seat and took their places eagerly to the strains of Winner Takes It All - not a reference to Jimmy Tarbuck, but the hit song by Abba. The Swedish Pop Gods were an unexpected musical accompaniment to the whole Mamma Mia experience and, although Matt and Cat are not avid Abba aficionados (or ABBAholics, as fanatics are known), they certainly prefer to tap their toes along to the multitudinous hits of the harmonious Euro-superstars than opera.
The menu had a good, if typical, range of Italian food; pasta, pizzas and salads. There was also a vast fish selection including stuffed trout, red snapper and 'ocean surprise' which was mostly various crustaceans with salad (£41). Cat was feeling hungry and chose ravioli sugo antico - Italian sausage with a garlic and tomato sauce. Matthew also plumped for ravioli, ravioli mari and monte - described as prawns, peppers, olives, mushrooms in garlic olive oil. Cat ordered a glass of red wine to wash down her sausage and was taken aback at the vast (250ml) glass. Perhaps she should have specified a small (125ml) drink. The habit of bars super-sizing drinks is a new and worrying phenomenon according to the government and, when checking this one drink on the NHS alcohol units calculator Cat was shocked to see that it potentially contained over three units of alcohol. Didn't stop her glugging it down though.
The melodious sounds of Abba continued to warble through the speakers, competing with the yelling of one of the many children in the restaurant. Did her mother know? Probably, as Mamma Mia is well-patronised by families and in the commendable Italian tradition they were all given a hearty welcome by the staff. This venue definitely gets a child-friendly tick, although the menu does not seem to explicitly make any concessions to younger visitors, e.g. smaller portions.
The main courses were served very promptly. Cat's bowl was filled with a good pile of ravioli with a concentrated tomato sauce and chunks of spicy sausage. A generous spoonful of Parmesan cheese was proffered by the waiter, topping the dish off nicely. It was all very tasty but the ravioli had a certain familiarity about it. Was it freshly made pasta created in the restaurant's kitchen or - as Matt suspected - something more generic?
Although Cat was pretty pleased with her choice of dish, Matt was more scathing. He didn't like the pasta because of its decidedly un-homemade nature. It was exactly the same pasta and filling that Cat had in her dish. Frankly, it tasted and looked just like the 'fresh pasta' that one can buy half-dried in supermarkets, even down to the tasteless paste of the filling. What's more, ravioli is normally square, or at least flat. These were neither. He was also underwhelmed with his dish's pretty bland mari and monte sauce, counting a mere three prawns. There were some unannounced mussels and some curious rubbery things which tasted decidedly fishy (squid?) but the dish was not as anticipated, or advertised. He mumbled as he mopped up the fishy liquid with some very nice cheesy garlic bread.
Matt and Cat's bill
Ravioli sugo antico £8.50
Ravioli mari and monte £8.50
Garlic bread £3.90
White wine (glass) £2.50
Ravioli sugo antico £8.50
Ravioli mari and monte £8.50
Garlic bread £3.90
White wine (glass) £2.50
More Abba tunes drifted through the air; Matt and Cat felt thankful for the music and did some synchronised nodding to 'Voulez-vous'. Cat finished off the glass of wine, Matt downed the rest of his Peroni beer and they looked out of the windows at the meandering pedestrians. M & C discussed what to have for pudding and decided that tiramisu was the only possible choice. Yet more Swedish songs yodelled their way through the ether - but no waiting staff were to be seen. 'I have a dream', said Cat, after some considerable time, '...it's of a marscapone and brandy dessert'. Finally catching the waiter's eye with an S.O.S. of her own, she asked for the tiramisu. Alas, there was none. Matt and Cat decided to leave but, by then, the waiter had cleared off before they could ask for the bill.
Yet more Abba - no waiter. You get the idea. Cat decided to take action and, making her way to the counter was tempted to shout "Gimme! Gimme! Gimme the bill". Money, money, money changed hands and Matt and Cat left to find coffee and pudding at Vernon Cottage, before finally taking their seats at Shanklin Theatre for 'two hours of chuckle therapy' with the legend that is Barry Cryer.
Matt and Cat were underwhelmed by Mamma Mia. The service was erratic, if amiable, and the food, whilst adequate, was neither particularly good nor especially cheap. There are several places across the Island where better Italian food can be had for as much or less - Olivo in Newport is perhaps the most obvious. Actually, it probably doesn't matter what Matt and Cat think - location is the name of the game and its extensive menu and friendly (if distracted) staff will probably be enough for Mamma Mia to succeed in this Summer Night City.
This is an archive review. Mamma Mia has now closed this restaurant and opened another. This review and the comments on it refer to the former venue.
Tweet
Visit the website: http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001630088581
Published: 8th September 200813094 views
Categories: We don't like, Restaurants, Family friendly, Sandown & Shanklin
96 comments
Comment from: jim howard
re 'Mamma Mia'- we visited when it had another name and the service and food was equally unimpressive (and not cheap) On that point, if you fancy a laugh, try The Mariners, Yarmouth. Coffee, tea and two, average pieces of cake - £9 !!
08/09/08 @ 19:22
Comment from: The Wildlife Gardener
They've got their ravioli mixed up with their tortellini. Ravioli can actually be circular, semi circular, rectangular etc and any size, but when it's pinched up to become a little 'belly button' it's tortellini. What a shame they didn't serve home-made pasta - it's not difficult!!
10/09/08 @ 10:31
Comment from: The Wildlife Gardener
Ooh - and a proper Italian restaurant will NEVER put parmesan on a seafood pasta.
10/09/08 @ 13:29
Comment from: stacey
i think the problem is although you are apparently food critics you dont seem to know much about food.
maybe you should stick to your mcdonalds or pizza hut and see how much a average dish will cost you there
Matt and Cat respond: thanks for the lesson in criticism, Stacey. We'll bear your advice in mind.
maybe you should stick to your mcdonalds or pizza hut and see how much a average dish will cost you there
Matt and Cat respond: thanks for the lesson in criticism, Stacey. We'll bear your advice in mind.
12/09/08 @ 14:23
Comment from: Natalie
I ate here with some friends a few months back. I will say that the food wasn't spectacular, it was nice and all but there seemed to be so much salt added that we were all gasping for our overpriced bottle of mineral water by the end, I'd reccomend trying Pizza Express before trying here...Thumbs down.
16/12/08 @ 17:19
Comment from: benny blanco
I totally agree with the comments about the service and the food!!
Apparently this is the same guy mario that used to own Pavarotti's in the old village.
Me and my wife tried both italians in shanklin and would say that Pavarotti's has much more to offer in the way of menu selection, staff competence and quality of food.
Only my opinion
Apparently this is the same guy mario that used to own Pavarotti's in the old village.
Me and my wife tried both italians in shanklin and would say that Pavarotti's has much more to offer in the way of menu selection, staff competence and quality of food.
Only my opinion
06/01/09 @ 20:21
Comment from: tony
hi ,
i must disagree with you there we eat here on a regular basis and is probly the best italian meal we have on the island.
fresh pizzas and a massive menu too chose from.
most places have frozen pizzas and over cooked pastas at least here its fresh.
i must disagree with you there we eat here on a regular basis and is probly the best italian meal we have on the island.
fresh pizzas and a massive menu too chose from.
most places have frozen pizzas and over cooked pastas at least here its fresh.
13/01/09 @ 11:52
Comment from: abbey
hi we went there a few times whilst on holiday on the island i must say the food was relly good and the staff also very friendly we enjoyed it very much and the kids loved the pizzas and amazed by the size of them!
i must say it was spot on!
i must say it was spot on!
24/01/09 @ 16:48
Comment from: Steve
I've been there several times and overall i very much enjoyed both the food and the service. I think it really does just come down to your personal taste. There is no comparison with the quality of the pizzas, the beverages, especially the beer and water are imported and rare on the island and its a place for all the family. The parmesan cheese is served at the table by the waiter at the request of the customer, therefore it would appear that Matt decided to take his seafood pasta to a whole new level... (food critic?).
Still, i recommend you give it another try, everytime i visit the establishment it pleases me on a different level.
Still, i recommend you give it another try, everytime i visit the establishment it pleases me on a different level.
26/01/09 @ 00:04
Comment from: mamma mia
hi thank you all for your comments and feedback good and bad!
when matt and cat visited we had only been open under 5 weeks and were still in the process of getting everything good and running including finding good atentive staff!
the sighn on the window must have got hit by wind before we had a chance to spot it and turn it around!
The cheese on the seafood pasta must have been requested by matt? because my waiters do serve parmesan at the table and not in the kitchen..
since open we have changed a lot of things including the menu now having over 100 dishes on the menu plus daily changing specials, and also a fixed team of good atentive staff.
thank you for your comments and would like to say pop in and give it another try as a lot of things have changed since we first opened a few months ago.
thankx
when matt and cat visited we had only been open under 5 weeks and were still in the process of getting everything good and running including finding good atentive staff!
the sighn on the window must have got hit by wind before we had a chance to spot it and turn it around!
The cheese on the seafood pasta must have been requested by matt? because my waiters do serve parmesan at the table and not in the kitchen..
since open we have changed a lot of things including the menu now having over 100 dishes on the menu plus daily changing specials, and also a fixed team of good atentive staff.
thank you for your comments and would like to say pop in and give it another try as a lot of things have changed since we first opened a few months ago.
thankx
05/02/09 @ 10:40
Comment from: Mrs D
We tried Mamma Mia's last night. Wasn't expecting much given the previous reviews, but were pleasantly surprised. We arrived at 8pm without booking and were lucky to get a table as a few parties coming in afterwards were turned away. Had a starter of mushrooms in a blue cheese sauce which was tasty (but had slightly too much parsley on top). Had a pizza for the main which looked handmade and was thin and crispy with plenty of topping. No room for pudding! Service was friendly, if a little rushed and we were neglected for a few minutes after the mains had been cleared. We were told that any leftover pizza could be boxed up to take home - nice touch. No major grumbles so will definately return.
17/05/09 @ 20:17
Comment from: steve
unbelievably bad.....the people running this place think their customers are stupid.....well, ok there were 9 of us and we sat down the garlic bread was ok...but what was to follow with the mains was a joke!
My wife, brother-in-law, mother in law and I all ordred dover sole and veg....the veg came and to say it was old would be an understatement...prob 3 days, maybe more.....we returned them and ordred salad.....they forgot one, so requested that.....my mum in law noticed that her 'dover sole' was NOT dover sole nor was my brother in laws....in fact they were LEMON SOLE...the waitress or was it the owner was adamant it was dover sole (yet they were totally different to mine and my wifes and we know what dover sole look and taste like!!!), but the attitude of the staff was a joke and they talked to her like an idiot.....until i pointed out she owns 2 restaurant bars in london and has been in the restaurant trade over 40 years....and has certainly eaten more fish than the owner of this rubbish restaurant!!
i will be reporting them to the IOW dept who dished out the joke 5 star award....this is THE worst italian restuarant ive ever been to
it was packed in there...dont know why - the music blaring should have been a hint
in isle of wight - shanklin - we went to morgans which was ok, service was rubbish though (had to move our own tables!!) but no atmoshphere and too clinical for my liking and pavrotti's (which was good and relaxing)
RANT OVER!
My wife, brother-in-law, mother in law and I all ordred dover sole and veg....the veg came and to say it was old would be an understatement...prob 3 days, maybe more.....we returned them and ordred salad.....they forgot one, so requested that.....my mum in law noticed that her 'dover sole' was NOT dover sole nor was my brother in laws....in fact they were LEMON SOLE...the waitress or was it the owner was adamant it was dover sole (yet they were totally different to mine and my wifes and we know what dover sole look and taste like!!!), but the attitude of the staff was a joke and they talked to her like an idiot.....until i pointed out she owns 2 restaurant bars in london and has been in the restaurant trade over 40 years....and has certainly eaten more fish than the owner of this rubbish restaurant!!
this is THE worst italian restuarant ive ever been to
my daughter wouldnt eat her carbonara - i tried it and ill eat anything but that was rank - tasted like the sauce was off...same goes for the other meals.....sister in laws pizza was terrible....so, of 8 meals only my son's mussels seemed ok...we didnt pay for the 2 'dover non-soles' i will be reporting them to the IOW dept who dished out the joke 5 star award....this is THE worst italian restuarant ive ever been to
it was packed in there...dont know why - the music blaring should have been a hint
in isle of wight - shanklin - we went to morgans which was ok, service was rubbish though (had to move our own tables!!) but no atmoshphere and too clinical for my liking and pavrotti's (which was good and relaxing)
RANT OVER!
12/08/09 @ 03:18
Comment from: Will
Oh my god Steve, you are soooooo funny. I doubt you would know the difference between a battered cod and a piece of sausage.
Still, I know it`s tough being let down, but someone in your position should really speak up whilst having your meal rather than ranting about it on a website making untrue speculations and insulting remarks regarding staff, food or service.
I tell you this because the vegetables are made fresh on a daily basis due to their high demand specially since the owners of this restaurant turn over roughly 150 people a day during peak season. Yet, you come in unannounced, get kindly seated; don´t leave the table when you are supposed to, making others who have booked that table wait, and then because of one mishap slate it all of as rubbish when everyone else`s plates were clean. (except for the bones of your `non dover sole`).
To sum it up, there are plenty of `Italian`restaurants on the island, pick any one you may prefer, except this one. I´m sure you will enjoy their pizzas a lot more.
Good night, god bless.
Still, I know it`s tough being let down, but someone in your position should really speak up whilst having your meal rather than ranting about it on a website making untrue speculations and insulting remarks regarding staff, food or service.
I tell you this because the vegetables are made fresh on a daily basis due to their high demand specially since the owners of this restaurant turn over roughly 150 people a day during peak season. Yet, you come in unannounced, get kindly seated; don´t leave the table when you are supposed to, making others who have booked that table wait, and then because of one mishap slate it all of as rubbish when everyone else`s plates were clean. (except for the bones of your `non dover sole`).
To sum it up, there are plenty of `Italian`restaurants on the island, pick any one you may prefer, except this one. I´m sure you will enjoy their pizzas a lot more.
Good night, god bless.
12/08/09 @ 16:49
Comment from: rachel
hi there,
we visited mamma mia`s two nights ago on our stay on the isle of wight, as we walked past my children had spotted the pizzas on a table by the window and begged us to go in!
all in all we really enjoyed our meal and the kids said they had eaten what they described as the biggest and bestest pizza ever!
the service was very good and the staff extremely friendly, although the place was fully booked and extremely busy the waiter on the door kindly prepared us a table which happend to be available for just under one and a half hours.
i have viewed the other comments left by others but must say we didnt have any faults to comment on, everyone had a good meal and a good time. we were amazed at the cue on the door to try and get in to this place!
all in all very good and we will be back!! next time we are on the island THANKS GUYS!!
regards rachel x
we visited mamma mia`s two nights ago on our stay on the isle of wight, as we walked past my children had spotted the pizzas on a table by the window and begged us to go in!
all in all we really enjoyed our meal and the kids said they had eaten what they described as the biggest and bestest pizza ever!
...the biggest and bestest pizza ever!
my husband had the fresh rack of lamb served with saute potatoes and mix vegetables whilst i had the spaghetti marinara all meals cooked to perfection and very good value for money. the service was very good and the staff extremely friendly, although the place was fully booked and extremely busy the waiter on the door kindly prepared us a table which happend to be available for just under one and a half hours.
i have viewed the other comments left by others but must say we didnt have any faults to comment on, everyone had a good meal and a good time. we were amazed at the cue on the door to try and get in to this place!
all in all very good and we will be back!! next time we are on the island THANKS GUYS!!
regards rachel x
16/08/09 @ 11:49
Comment from: lovefood
Had a good value meal here with my mates in March.Starter and main where tasty and filling I did however get served Tesco value Strawberry mousse for pudding and it was low calorie....yuk. I Know it was part of a special offer but I have never experienced this. We know the origin of the pud because we could see the packet through the hatch! What a shame, haven't felt like returning. Not sure I will.
22/08/09 @ 18:15
Comment from: janet
Hi all....
my husband and i eat at mamma mias about 3 times a week during march when they had a special set menu , 3courses for ONLY 10 POUNDS ! it was fantastic never had a problem everyday they had a choice of different pudings. for 10 pounds you can hardly find a maincourse at that price let alone 3 courses!! 10/10
my husband and i eat at mamma mias about 3 times a week during march when they had a special set menu , 3courses for ONLY 10 POUNDS ! it was fantastic never had a problem everyday they had a choice of different pudings. for 10 pounds you can hardly find a maincourse at that price let alone 3 courses!! 10/10
24/08/09 @ 13:06
Comment from: Carol
Returned from a recent holiday on the Isle of Wight and found mamma mia's by luck, I have never wrote a reveiw before but the food was so fantastic I felt I had to, can't believe the negative vibes from other reviews. I had mussels in tomato and chilli sauce, hugh pile - gorgeous, then seabas done to perfection. The atmosphere was a bit chaotic but because we were with teenage kids they loved it (not the place for a quite romantic meal).
28/08/09 @ 11:27
Comment from: Kay
Despite some of the negative comments on here, Mamma Mia's is still going strong and for very good reason. The food is very good, the service is snappy and it's great value for money.
I lived in Italy for some while and I have to say that the pizzas here rival anything I have eaten over there.
Only one slight disappointment for me. I ordered risotto and was very surprised to find that it was made with Basmati rice. I queried it at the time and apparently the chef "prefers to do it that way". Well, it was tasty, but for me it is the short grain rice (Arborio or similar) that makes it a real risotto. Won't be ordering that again, but I will definitely be going back soon.
I lived in Italy for some while and I have to say that the pizzas here rival anything I have eaten over there.
Only one slight disappointment for me. I ordered risotto and was very surprised to find that it was made with Basmati rice. I queried it at the time and apparently the chef "prefers to do it that way". Well, it was tasty, but for me it is the short grain rice (Arborio or similar) that makes it a real risotto. Won't be ordering that again, but I will definitely be going back soon.
07/09/09 @ 23:11
Comment from: KJ
I would add that very many of our visitors have eaten there over this summer and only one had a complaint...everybody else has really enjoyed it.
The one complaint was about the Lobster thermiador being overdressed
The one complaint was about the Lobster thermiador being overdressed
08/09/09 @ 19:41
Comment from: John
I took my family here a few weeks ago, wish i was presented with a 3 course for 10 pounds offer. Our bill came to 90 quid or so thats with 2 children and 2 Adults. We ordered starters and mains and finished off with dessert. Luckily neither of us bought alcohol otherwise we would have been doing the washing up. I ordered spicy garlic pasta, which frankly tasted bland and more like a it came out of a packet and it had that awful monotoned flavour, i knew i should have gone for the fish!
I would give mama mia 2/10, it was extortionate and after reading the above comments it seems i must be in an elitist club to receive discounts, promotions or decent service.
I would give mama mia 2/10, it was extortionate and after reading the above comments it seems i must be in an elitist club to receive discounts, promotions or decent service.
22/11/09 @ 20:49
Comment from: mamma mia restaurant
regarding the last comment from john:
every customer is presented with a 3 course meal offer that commenced on 25th october if you then choose to order perhaps off the main menu then the prices are stated so no confusion could be had..
frankly to be honest i feel this is a false accusation simply to be hurtfull rather then a genuine feed back comment from a customer.
every customer is presented with a 3 course meal offer that commenced on 25th october if you then choose to order perhaps off the main menu then the prices are stated so no confusion could be had..
frankly to be honest i feel this is a false accusation simply to be hurtfull rather then a genuine feed back comment from a customer.
23/11/09 @ 19:19
Comment from: Lauren Newsham
I live 1 minuute away from this restaurant and have eaten there on many occasions. I have absolutely no complaints whatsoever. Infact, we are going there tonight providing we can get a table and providing the 3 courses for a tenner is still available!At this hard time within the economy, it's places like Mamma Mias that allow you to have a nice evening out with your family without breaking the bank! I am looking forward to eating there later so well done guys....no complaints from the Newshams!
27/11/09 @ 15:59
On a visit to relatives, we went to eat at Mamma Mia's this evening. There were 8 of us altogether.
The meal was outstanding; reasonably priced and the helpings were excellent.
I have to say that it is most certainly the best meal I've had at a restaurant in a good many years.
23/01/10 @ 23:15
Comment from: Liberty
Yum!!! We LOVE Mamma Mias and have eaten there every few weeks since we found the place purely by accident because the restaurant we were going to was shut!! We eat from the 3 courses for £10 menu and take our 2 children (2 and 6) and the staff are wonderful with them. Our kids (one of whom eats very little usually) always eat loads and love it. The food is fresh and staff are friendly. There are usually 6-8 of us and we have NEVER had a bad meal there - i really recommend this restaurant and from our experience they deserve the trade. We will definitely be going back again.
29/03/10 @ 10:47
Comment from: Mamma Mias
Hello to everyone.
Just to let you all know that the photo of the establishment as well as the actual prices once quoted by Matt and Cat no longer apply, it would therefore be much appreciated if they could revise or update them, since apart from their own opinion which they are entitled to, all the other details regarding the establishment are incorrect, be it the pricing, the "shabby outside look" of the establishment from when it first opened etc.
Therefore it would be appreciated if the above information be revised as to avoid misinforming the general public.
Thank you.
Matt and Cat respond: Thanks for your comments, Mamma Mias. Feel free to use this website to clarify any points about our review that you feel are no longer relevant. We may visit again and, if we do, we'll amend our review of September 2008 if appropriate. Kind regards, Matt and Cat.
Just to let you all know that the photo of the establishment as well as the actual prices once quoted by Matt and Cat no longer apply, it would therefore be much appreciated if they could revise or update them, since apart from their own opinion which they are entitled to, all the other details regarding the establishment are incorrect, be it the pricing, the "shabby outside look" of the establishment from when it first opened etc.
Therefore it would be appreciated if the above information be revised as to avoid misinforming the general public.
Thank you.
Matt and Cat respond: Thanks for your comments, Mamma Mias. Feel free to use this website to clarify any points about our review that you feel are no longer relevant. We may visit again and, if we do, we'll amend our review of September 2008 if appropriate. Kind regards, Matt and Cat.
04/05/10 @ 18:07
Comment from: Tina watson
we visit the isle of wight around twice a year and usually stay in Sandown, however this year we decided to stay at shanklin.
we tend to eat out on a daily basis whilst on vacation and mamma mia's was one of our favourites. we visited a total of 3 times during a 5 day break as my teenage daughter seemed to have a crush on the young waiter! Each and every time service and food was brilliant.
We always felt welcomed and would be visiting again on our next visit.
Thank you guys!
we tend to eat out on a daily basis whilst on vacation and mamma mia's was one of our favourites. we visited a total of 3 times during a 5 day break as my teenage daughter seemed to have a crush on the young waiter! Each and every time service and food was brilliant.
We always felt welcomed and would be visiting again on our next visit.
Thank you guys!
22/05/10 @ 13:39
Comment from: Anna P
I stumbled across this review whilst searching around for Mamma Mia's website - having enjoyed an excellent meal there this week, my family and I were curious to learn a little more about the place.
Reading Matt and Cat's review, though, I have to say I wondered at first if we really had the same restaurant in mind! I really think it a shame that this apparently very out-dated review continues to top the list of hits returned by Google when one is searching online for the place.
While no expert foodie, I have lived in Italy for a time, and found the pizzas on offer at Mamma Mia among the few I have found in England which manage to emulate the quality of the real deal. As for the ravioli mari e monte that Matt found so disappointing, I found the sauce to be absolutely delicious! Everyone in our party (little ones included) found the food to be of excellent quality, the portions generous, and the service extremely friendly.
For those who might be reading this who have yet to visit Mamma Mia, I urge you to ignore both the picture above and the original review and to go and try it for yourselves. Matt and Cat, i think you should get yourselves back there for a couple of massive, authentic pizzas and some delicious tiramisu - i am sure it won't fail to sweeten your opinion!
Reading Matt and Cat's review, though, I have to say I wondered at first if we really had the same restaurant in mind! I really think it a shame that this apparently very out-dated review continues to top the list of hits returned by Google when one is searching online for the place.
While no expert foodie, I have lived in Italy for a time, and found the pizzas on offer at Mamma Mia among the few I have found in England which manage to emulate the quality of the real deal. As for the ravioli mari e monte that Matt found so disappointing, I found the sauce to be absolutely delicious! Everyone in our party (little ones included) found the food to be of excellent quality, the portions generous, and the service extremely friendly.
For those who might be reading this who have yet to visit Mamma Mia, I urge you to ignore both the picture above and the original review and to go and try it for yourselves. Matt and Cat, i think you should get yourselves back there for a couple of massive, authentic pizzas and some delicious tiramisu - i am sure it won't fail to sweeten your opinion!
29/08/10 @ 00:26
Comment from: Simon From Mamma Mia · http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001630088581
Hi guys!!!
Just to let you know that we know have a page on Facebook with the details of the latest menus and special offers available. Check out MammaMia Shanklin and be the first ones to be in the know and look out for some very special promotions only available through Facebook!
Regards.
Just to let you know that we know have a page on Facebook with the details of the latest menus and special offers available. Check out MammaMia Shanklin and be the first ones to be in the know and look out for some very special promotions only available through Facebook!
Regards.
07/10/10 @ 18:30
Comment from: Trevor and Donna
DEAR MATT AND CAT,
WE THINK THAT YOUR SERVICES AS CRITICS ARE VERY WELCOME OVERALL, BUT IF YOU SLATE A NEWLY OPENED RESTAURANT (WHO BY ITS OWN ADMISSION HAS CHANGED ANY ERRORS) AND MANY SATISFIED CUSTOMERS OFFER NICER OPINIONS WHICH ARE MORE UP TO DATE, PLEASE GIVE THE COURTESY OF RETURNING AND UPDATING YOUR OPINION. IT MUST BE HARD ENOUGH MAKING A LIVING, LET ALONE BEING PUT DOWN FOR SOMETHING YOU ARE NOT!! MAMMA MIA'S IS A LOVELY, WELCOMING AND FRIENDLY PLACE TO EAT. NOT POSH NOSH, BUT DELIGHTFUL FOOD AND AUTHENTICALY ITALIAN. WE LOVE THE RESTAURANT AND RECOMMEND ALL TO TRY IT, YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED. THE PRICES ARE SPOT ON AND CURRENTLY HAVE A BRILLIANT 3 COURSE WINTER OFFER FOR £12.99.
COME ON MATT AND CAT, WE LOOK TO YOU FOR UP TO DATE REVIEWS. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK, JUST KEEP IT CURRENT
Matt and Cat: {rub ears}
WE THINK THAT YOUR SERVICES AS CRITICS ARE VERY WELCOME OVERALL, BUT IF YOU SLATE A NEWLY OPENED RESTAURANT (WHO BY ITS OWN ADMISSION HAS CHANGED ANY ERRORS) AND MANY SATISFIED CUSTOMERS OFFER NICER OPINIONS WHICH ARE MORE UP TO DATE, PLEASE GIVE THE COURTESY OF RETURNING AND UPDATING YOUR OPINION. IT MUST BE HARD ENOUGH MAKING A LIVING, LET ALONE BEING PUT DOWN FOR SOMETHING YOU ARE NOT!! MAMMA MIA'S IS A LOVELY, WELCOMING AND FRIENDLY PLACE TO EAT. NOT POSH NOSH, BUT DELIGHTFUL FOOD AND AUTHENTICALY ITALIAN. WE LOVE THE RESTAURANT AND RECOMMEND ALL TO TRY IT, YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED. THE PRICES ARE SPOT ON AND CURRENTLY HAVE A BRILLIANT 3 COURSE WINTER OFFER FOR £12.99.
COME ON MATT AND CAT, WE LOOK TO YOU FOR UP TO DATE REVIEWS. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK, JUST KEEP IT CURRENT
Matt and Cat: {rub ears}
25/10/10 @ 10:48
Comment from: TREVOR AND DONNA
HI MATT AND CAT,
WE WERE WONDERING WHAT 'RUB EARS' MEANS IN RESPONSE TO OUR COMMENTS ON MAMMA MIA'S? PLEASE ELABORATE AS WE ARE NOW MAKING BETS ON WHAT SUCH A STRANGE REPLY COULD BE.
ON ANOTHER NOTE, WE MADE AN ERROR IN OUR EARLIER COMMENTS, THE WINTER SPECIAL THIS YEAR IS £12.00 NOT £12.99, SUCH GOOD VALUE.
WE ATE THERE AGAIN THIS WEEK, AND STILL RECOMMEND ALL TO TRY THIS FOR YOURSELVES. WE ALL HAVE DIFFERENT TASTES AND REQUIREMENTS, INCLUDING FOORD CRITICS
Matt & Cat reply: This link takes you to an article concerning those who write in capitals. Thanks for your continuing input, Trevor and Donna. We look forward to reading more from you in the future in whatever case you prefer - and maybe about some other restaurants, too.
WE WERE WONDERING WHAT 'RUB EARS' MEANS IN RESPONSE TO OUR COMMENTS ON MAMMA MIA'S? PLEASE ELABORATE AS WE ARE NOW MAKING BETS ON WHAT SUCH A STRANGE REPLY COULD BE.
ON ANOTHER NOTE, WE MADE AN ERROR IN OUR EARLIER COMMENTS, THE WINTER SPECIAL THIS YEAR IS £12.00 NOT £12.99, SUCH GOOD VALUE.
WE ATE THERE AGAIN THIS WEEK, AND STILL RECOMMEND ALL TO TRY THIS FOR YOURSELVES. WE ALL HAVE DIFFERENT TASTES AND REQUIREMENTS, INCLUDING FOORD CRITICS
Matt & Cat reply: This link takes you to an article concerning those who write in capitals. Thanks for your continuing input, Trevor and Donna. We look forward to reading more from you in the future in whatever case you prefer - and maybe about some other restaurants, too.
05/11/10 @ 09:01
Comment from: Tracy
"Rub Ears" = you've deafened us, with all your shouting!
Please use lower case in normal dialogue.
Please use lower case in normal dialogue.
05/11/10 @ 23:51
Comment from: Sue
Both my husband and I love Mamma Mia!!! We eat there a lot and have never had a bad meal. It remains one of the most popular places to eat in the area and the food, staff and music are all GREAT!!
24/11/10 @ 16:16
Comment from: daniel tredinnick
I feel I have to say that these guys are professional in everything they do and being itallian themselves they know what itallian food should be! I must point out though that I used to work at pavarottis and after a few teething problems the proprietors of mamma mias have really turned it around and I had christmas dinner there which was great. I had the mamma mia pizza and the parmasan was offered at the table. I couldn't even finish it as I was so full and the staff were really friendly as if I was in their italian home.
05/01/11 @ 17:33
Comment from: Bushy
We took our graddaughters aged six and four last Friday lunchtime before going to see Aladdin. We had a very warm welcome from an Italian lady, who made a fuss of the children. They tucked into pasta with tomato and cheese sauce, which looked very home made and had a fair bit of garlic in it. We had pizzas which werre excellent - maybe a bit lacking in presentation but very tasty. All in all, a good experience. This has more of a family cafe rather than an Italian restaurant atmosphere, but what it does it does well - certainly not deserving of a 'don't like' rating. Probably one for Matt & Cat to try again...?
07/01/11 @ 12:35
Comment from: Mammamia · http://medasrestaurants.com
To all our customers,
We will soon be opening our new restaurant "Mammamia 2" in the sandown area.
With a large capacity seating for over 90 people due to the ever increasing demand for tables!!
Further details to follow, visit our website medasrestaurants.com for further details.
Opening date will shortly follow and for all our existing customers you will be invited to our opening party!
Thankyou
We will soon be opening our new restaurant "Mammamia 2" in the sandown area.
With a large capacity seating for over 90 people due to the ever increasing demand for tables!!
Further details to follow, visit our website medasrestaurants.com for further details.
Opening date will shortly follow and for all our existing customers you will be invited to our opening party!
Thankyou
06/02/11 @ 18:34
Comment from: John Woodhouse
We dined there last night. Warm welcome, good service, super food & good value - will definitely return. Only slight negative was quite noisy - not sure whether due to being busy (a good sign) or shape of room
23/02/11 @ 19:01
Comment from: Christie-Lee 
It is amazing that such bad comments have come for this resturaunt.
A group of 12 of us went last weekend we Pre-Booked a table and had a very enjoyable evening.
The food was plentiful and extreamly tasty! Between the 12 of us we managed to try alot of the different things on the menu and must say that nothing was below absolute satifaction.
The service was great the staff friendly and could not do enough to help.
The price was very reasonable, we all had three courses and most of us were drinking also and our meal came to just £18 a head, i think extreamly good value for money. Also not one of us would of Objected to paying more as everything was Delicious and the portions were plentiful.
Over all I would recomend this resurant to any one who enjoys fresh, Tasty Italian food.
We all loved it and will definatly be going there again!
A group of 12 of us went last weekend we Pre-Booked a table and had a very enjoyable evening.
The food was plentiful and extreamly tasty! Between the 12 of us we managed to try alot of the different things on the menu and must say that nothing was below absolute satifaction.
The service was great the staff friendly and could not do enough to help.
The price was very reasonable, we all had three courses and most of us were drinking also and our meal came to just £18 a head, i think extreamly good value for money. Also not one of us would of Objected to paying more as everything was Delicious and the portions were plentiful.
Over all I would recomend this resurant to any one who enjoys fresh, Tasty Italian food.
We all loved it and will definatly be going there again!
04/03/11 @ 10:52
Comment from: Mamma Mia · http://medasrestaurants.com
Hi guys, just to remind you all that we open Mamma Mia 2 Pasta factory tomorrow 10/3/11. We will be open from about 10am in order to just add our finishing touches to the place.
We hope to see you there be it for breakfast, lunch, coffees or dinner we do it all at Mamma Mia's 2 Pasta Factory.
You can check all our menus online so don't forget to visit our website for details!!!
See you there!!!
We hope to see you there be it for breakfast, lunch, coffees or dinner we do it all at Mamma Mia's 2 Pasta Factory.
You can check all our menus online so don't forget to visit our website for details!!!
See you there!!!
09/03/11 @ 18:04
Comment from: Sean
We visited Mamma Mia’s in Shanklin on Friday Night for Tea, and to try their £12 set menu. Having read reviews here I was not sure what to expect, but it was really good, of course good value for money, but the food was great too. Often with set menu’s you do not seem to get the quality or quantity as normal, not here, the portions were so generous and the quality was really top notch. We are returning this week and taking the family. It is worth a try, great food and friendly staff, made for a great experience, well done mamma Mia’s, we will try your new restaurant in Sandown soon as well.
21/03/11 @ 07:47
Comment from: Sean
We returned with a party of 8 on Friday evening for Tea, the place was packed and they were turning peeps away, so they are doing something right. Our service and meals were first class, and fantastic value at just £12 for 3 courses. We take as we find and really enjoyed our 2 dining experiences at Mamma Mia's. Thankyou for another great night out!
29/03/11 @ 11:19
Comment from: Phillipa
I have eaten in mamma mia's a few times now and have never been disappointed with the service or the food. I think it's very well priced for the amount you are served and is a lively and welcoming place. I will happily eat there again
04/04/11 @ 21:35
Comment from: bigeater
I havenet eaten here - but walked past plenty of times -
To the owner - the place looks shabby, the sign age hasn't changed from the previous business. ( lazy) the interior is poorly painted - might look ok on the costa del sol, but it winds me up that a business cant even be bothered to make their new venture premises look even presentable....old signs in place, covered with tacky vinyl sign, windows steaming up. PLease make the effort - people expect more .. mamma mia2 ? please ..... get the first one up to scratch first ... !
I notice its always busy, is that because the foods good or is it that it the only other family dining in shanklin bar the crab ?
To the owner - the place looks shabby, the sign age hasn't changed from the previous business. ( lazy) the interior is poorly painted - might look ok on the costa del sol, but it winds me up that a business cant even be bothered to make their new venture premises look even presentable....old signs in place, covered with tacky vinyl sign, windows steaming up. PLease make the effort - people expect more .. mamma mia2 ? please ..... get the first one up to scratch first ... !
I notice its always busy, is that because the foods good or is it that it the only other family dining in shanklin bar the crab ?
22/05/11 @ 11:25
Comment from: mauro
tanks bigeater your expertise in paint e decorations and your comentary is a compliment nex time pass by put on your glasses
22/05/11 @ 12:21
Comment from: Will
My god Bigeater, what a rather pointless slander you just made...
You come across as nothing short than a sad, lonely individual with nothing better to do than rumble on about coplete nonsense.
Well you obviously know us well enough to realise we have indeed opened up a new business in Sandown, perhaps you would like to give us a quote for the renovation of the place... I was just wondering if by any chance you are the bearded man that walks past everyday and talks to his polystirine coffee cup?
You come across as nothing short than a sad, lonely individual with nothing better to do than rumble on about coplete nonsense.
Well you obviously know us well enough to realise we have indeed opened up a new business in Sandown, perhaps you would like to give us a quote for the renovation of the place... I was just wondering if by any chance you are the bearded man that walks past everyday and talks to his polystirine coffee cup?
23/05/11 @ 18:35
Comment from: kj
sometimes owners should learn NOT to reply. Everybody is capable of an opinion and your derision is in bad taste
23/05/11 @ 19:52
Comment from: polystirinecoffeecupman
Dear Miss,
I have been accused of a great many things, ignoring my coffee shall never, NEVER be one of them.
Yours,
Me
I have been accused of a great many things, ignoring my coffee shall never, NEVER be one of them.
Yours,
Me
23/05/11 @ 21:23
Comment from: Ali
Oh dear, the proprietors made a first class response initially, textbook perfect way to respond to criticism. 'Will' seems determined to make them appear amateurish and petulant though. Perhaps s/he should remember potential customers are reading this? :O
23/05/11 @ 21:38
Comment from: Will
Owner ?? no. I just work there, never the less, I too am entitled to my own opinion and speculation.
23/05/11 @ 22:21
Comment from: Trevor and Donna
What an interesting conversation building up about Mamma Mia Shanklin ! Whilst it is without doubt one of the best places to eat in the town, it can be said that a redecoration project would be welcomed. We have often visited many eateries that are immaculate in front of house, but not up to scratch when the food is served. Mamma Mias' food is of a very good quality and you never leave hungry, so for what it is worth, we would prefer an owner to spend their money on the food on my plate first and re-decorate later.
Trevor and Donna
Trevor and Donna
07/06/11 @ 09:55
Comment from: from mauro
tanks trevor and donna at mamma mia is not abbot spend money the owner of the building not let make any work inside or out for this we buy big place in shanklin and we move sun in to at new plaice and you and donna are in my guest list for the opening day........................................non coment for criticism made by others
07/06/11 @ 17:25
Comment from: julian
have you ever been back to mamma mias if so whats it like now do you ever go back to any
Matt & Cat respond: No, we haven't yet although we certainly have it on our list. Some people seem to like it so by all means give it a go - it was a long time ago we went so it might well have changed.
Matt & Cat respond: No, we haven't yet although we certainly have it on our list. Some people seem to like it so by all means give it a go - it was a long time ago we went so it might well have changed.
28/08/11 @ 19:18
Comment from: julian
went into mamma mias on friday 16th 09 2011 well if you want fake italian food its the one for you its staff are more intrested in the own life not serving food or drinks when i went and paid i was told to wait till the girls finshed what they did last night not very good at all total let down allso if you claim to be italian serve itailin food dont try and do english food
17/09/11 @ 15:16
Comment from: CJD
M & C you may want to run that last comment through an on-line translator...... :-)
Matt and Cat respond: thank you, we've deleted the comment. Really, we encourage restaurants to participate but we don't think it's good form for them to swear at their customers, even in Italian.
Matt and Cat respond: thank you, we've deleted the comment. Really, we encourage restaurants to participate but we don't think it's good form for them to swear at their customers, even in Italian.
22/09/11 @ 21:39
Comment from: Kate
I have to agree with the comments that Mama Mia's in Shanklin looks a bit shabby and dirty. Coupled with the very low hygiene rating score of 2, it didn't engender a feeling of confidence so we walked past. I must say that the place was heaving with diners though, and the laughter was ringing outside the restaurant. It made me wonder whether they knew about the hygiene rating or whether they just didn't mind?
23/09/11 @ 14:12
Comment from: Mamma Mias · http://medasrestaurants.com
There is already a discussion on this website regarding the stars on doors schemes and the disappointment which followed among many business owners on the council reviewing the scores, so there really is little point to open the doors to another discussion regarding this issue.
Yes our restaurant is a busy one and many nights are filled with delighted giggling customers but perhaps these are the types of people that don't base their lives on government guidelines, but rather a great atmosphere, great food and great service, if this is the case then we say it's a breath of fresh air.
Either way Mamma Mia's will be closing very soon and moving on to a different local. We therefore thank all our existing customers. Details of this will be available soon on our website.
Yes our restaurant is a busy one and many nights are filled with delighted giggling customers but perhaps these are the types of people that don't base their lives on government guidelines, but rather a great atmosphere, great food and great service, if this is the case then we say it's a breath of fresh air.
Either way Mamma Mia's will be closing very soon and moving on to a different local. We therefore thank all our existing customers. Details of this will be available soon on our website.
23/09/11 @ 17:30
Comment from: Mammamia
p.s when we close this lovely reviews must be removed and we make sure not to be appear anymore on this web site
23/09/11 @ 17:41
Comment from: MrsD
Have just read this post re closure to my 4 year old daughter who has flung herself on the floor
sobbing "please don't close Mamma Mia's". Please open again in Shanklin very soon!
sobbing "please don't close Mamma Mia's". Please open again in Shanklin very soon!
23/09/11 @ 18:07
Comment from: kj
how do you propose to stop you customers writing reviews, Matt & Cats opinions make up less than half the comments on here...the vast majority are from other customers
23/09/11 @ 19:02
Comment from: Den
Beautiful meals, I proposed there and it was the only place I would ever have chosen, the night went brilliantly. The food was delicious and she said... well, that is not what matters!!!!! The food is incredible and I recommend it to everybody.
23/09/11 @ 20:57
Comment from: Jasmine · http://www.facebook.com
Win 52 meals at our new establishment thats a whole year!
I would love to win this as my partner and I eat at this resaurant quite regulary, they serve lovely food and at good prices. Service always comes with a smile from the family. True Italiano :D x
I would love to win this as my partner and I eat at this resaurant quite regulary, they serve lovely food and at good prices. Service always comes with a smile from the family. True Italiano :D x
23/09/11 @ 21:06
Comment from: kirsty
We are a busy Island family and very rarely get an adult night out, but when we do there are no hesitations on where we are going...The food is always delicious, the service always perfect and a great atmosphere....everywhere has off days, even the best restaurants, we have never experienced this at mamma mias.
23/09/11 @ 21:17
Comment from: Mammamia
to kj is not my choice to be here my personal details or anytingh related to my business no body have the rigth to use for promote the on web site and make money
23/09/11 @ 21:18
Comment from: rachel
have been to your restaurant for work outings,romantic evenings, and dining out with the kids a fantastic time had by all! Service is warm friendly and amazing food is always served with a smile recommend you to everyone i know and also to people i dont know! never experienced an off day within there restaurant or hav ever heard anything bad from anyone Keep up the good work at mamma mia's i will be back soon for another one of your fantastic meals
23/09/11 @ 21:57
Mamma Mia here I go again....my my how can I resist ya
Mamma mia does it show again....my my just how much I missed ya
Yes I've been broken hearted, blue since the day we parted
But I hope that I win the competiton so we can be united once again ;o
Mamma mia does it show again....my my just how much I missed ya
Yes I've been broken hearted, blue since the day we parted
But I hope that I win the competiton so we can be united once again ;o
23/09/11 @ 22:38
Comment from: kj
so...how are you going to stop your customers writing reviews.....just sounds like you have no respect for your customers views.
Matt & Cat run this site for fun, not money, nobody pays to use it and it carrys no advertising.
Get over yourself...some people are going to love your food, some are going to hate
Matt & Cat run this site for fun, not money, nobody pays to use it and it carrys no advertising.
Get over yourself...some people are going to love your food, some are going to hate
24/09/11 @ 02:53
Comment from: Suzie
Well, I for one have always rated Mamma Mia's, love the atmosphere, always cheerful and relaxed and friendly no matter how busy they are, and personally have always found the food excellent. Very much looking forward to their new venture.
24/09/11 @ 05:51
Comment from: from mauro
to kj yeah 25 pound for a card ? is not free we due the privileg card in 1995 and we give away for free wen we run pavarottis im to old to keep this crap
24/09/11 @ 08:32
Comment from: Jane
I ate here a few days back with my husband the food was lovely and the service was great i would certainly go there again
24/09/11 @ 13:09
Comment from: will
Kj it would appear that mamma mia is actually encouraging its customers to tell everyone that reads this site what they think. problem is that for some reason rather than so much critizising food some are more concerned about paint jobs and wall fixtures, and they havent even eaten there. most people eat with their eyes anyway but shouldnt people at least try something before slating it into the ground? I mean how would you feel if u dedicated the whole morning and afternoon and maybe the night before organising a bbq for ur neighbours, only to find a handfull slating ur event to everyone else because u didnt have time to trim ur edges? Im sure u would find that offensive. maybe he does ' need to get overhimself' but the last few negative comments had little to do with food. as for matt and cat running this site for fun, yes in the beginning no doubt this was the case, but it is clearly a lucritive hobby. At the end of the day dont we all wish to make money doing what we enjoy doing?
24/09/11 @ 13:52
Comment from: will
Oh and kj... f.y.i. i doubt those internet trolls would pay to post comments about shabby paintjobs if they had to pau, same as you and me wouldnt waste time herw if we were bound to a membership fee through this site... so ye, of course its free.. lol
24/09/11 @ 13:57
Comment from: local business man
I would like to start off by saying looks can be deceiving i eat out every single day of the year on the island for lunch and can say i have tried 85% of the places that offer food ranging from snacks to indian, chinease, italian and fast food and cannot say that there are many consistent nice places around.
Many of the nicest looking establishments with thousands of pounds worth of fixtures and decorations should have invested more of that on a descent chef and quality food!
I have eaten several times at mammamias and havent found a fault with the food or establishment, maybe it doesnt look like a posh stuck up venue offering small portions at high prices and thats why people love it. Its cosy, friendly and descent which is more then i can say for a lot of the other places near by.
Many of the nicest looking establishments with thousands of pounds worth of fixtures and decorations should have invested more of that on a descent chef and quality food!
I have eaten several times at mammamias and havent found a fault with the food or establishment, maybe it doesnt look like a posh stuck up venue offering small portions at high prices and thats why people love it. Its cosy, friendly and descent which is more then i can say for a lot of the other places near by.
24/09/11 @ 14:02
Comment from: iowmummy
i have yet to try mamma mias food, im a very busy 20yr old mother of 1 and rarely get a night out, after reading the reviews i am very intrigued to do so. I have only ever heard positive feedback from friends and family who have attended this italian restaurant. I am hoping to try your food out very soon and cant wait to do so! as for the "bad reviews" perhaps a civil conversation with the proprietors would have been more convenient, rather than slating the restaurant over the internet for all to see, therefore perhaps putting people off and not developing their own opinion, I however try to focus on the good reviews and definatly intend to pay you guys a visit! see you soon x
24/09/11 @ 17:47
Comment from: kj
if it helps, I have eaten at Pavarottis when you had it and MammaMias and have no complaints at all ( loved Pavs back then).....but you have to accept that some people won't like the restaurant and will post about it whatever you say and do.
You seldom learn from good criticism...but should always learn from bad, and abusing people that have an opinion is not going to win you customers.
You seldom learn from good criticism...but should always learn from bad, and abusing people that have an opinion is not going to win you customers.
24/09/11 @ 19:23
Comments were temporarily suspended on this review because some of the comments didn't comply with our commenting policy.
We're now turned the comments back on. We are delighted to hear about the Mamma Mia competition and wish all the commenters the best of luck in winning a meal for two for a whole year! (Competition open until 1 October). What a great idea, and thanks Mamma Mia for supporting our website.
So please leave your thoughts again, but do be polite in your comments, and don't spoil the competition for everyone else.
We're now turned the comments back on. We are delighted to hear about the Mamma Mia competition and wish all the commenters the best of luck in winning a meal for two for a whole year! (Competition open until 1 October). What a great idea, and thanks Mamma Mia for supporting our website.
So please leave your thoughts again, but do be polite in your comments, and don't spoil the competition for everyone else.
24/09/11 @ 19:46
Comment from: Clive Bishop
Another great review - However at least with this venue i have already reviewed it myself on several occassions and concur its a great place to eat.
And to top it off - a chance to eat there for a WHOLE year - errrr yes please!!
And to top it off - a chance to eat there for a WHOLE year - errrr yes please!!
27/09/11 @ 22:53
Comment from: Debbie Hill
Have eaten at Mamma Mia's a couple of times, we had Christmas Dinner there last year and the best by far.Booking this year too
The food was amazing and your are not rushed, but left to enjoy the meal in peace and very reasonably priced too.
A lovely Restaurant,No expensive prices or over the top Advertising.
Just Great Food and very welcoming Hospitality
The food was amazing and your are not rushed, but left to enjoy the meal in peace and very reasonably priced too.
A lovely Restaurant,No expensive prices or over the top Advertising.
Just Great Food and very welcoming Hospitality
27/09/11 @ 23:28
Comment from: Em
I have often passed Mamma Mia's but have never been in. However after reading all these comments, if money weren't so tight, I would definatly book a table just to see for myself what it was like! With 2 kids (aged 2 and 4) eating out is a luxury we don't often have and to hear that Mamma Mia's is child friendly makes it on my list of places to try for a pay-day treat.
28/09/11 @ 00:08
Comment from: lindsey
great place to eat been there a few times :) and even greater to eat there for a whole year FREE :)
28/09/11 @ 00:43
Comment from: Albo
Is this where to leave a comment for free dinner? if so DONE ;-).
28/09/11 @ 09:14
Comment from: Mikeiow
Having lived in Shanklin for over ten years now we have experienced most of the Islands and local town resturants and eateries, Mama Mia's is one resturant we keep going back to, fresh home cooked food providing fresh pasta dishes, relaxed atmosphere and friendly service creating that feel good factor that not all resturants can achieve, well done to Lillian and her staff !.
28/09/11 @ 16:45
Comment from: Jackie
As a single mum, working part time hours as a carer for the elderly, eating out is not within my budget. I have had many recommendations and would love to come along and try some of your chefs creations. I'll keep playing the lottery and hope to get lucky!! :)
28/09/11 @ 21:40
Comment from: mandy
have walked past a few times but have not come in yet, would love to sample some of the dishes
29/09/11 @ 07:38
Comment from: Sean
We have been visiting since March (see comments here in March) after our first visit we went back the following week with all the family. Since then we use the restaurant regularly because we love the food and atmosphere, and the relaxed friendly staff help make the night. We always find the food and wine on offer very good…“Uno non può pensare bene, amare bene, dormire bene, se non ha mangiato bene”
29/09/11 @ 08:07
Comment from: Iain B
We found Mamma Mia's on a holiday to the IOW a few years ago now and loved it! We as a family come from Portsmouth but once every couple of months we have a day trip to the island, but we make sure to book a late ferry just to have an Italian! The food is wonderful, reasonably priced and the staff very friendly. We would certainly recommend Mamma Mia's to anyone as there there is truly something for everyone.
29/09/11 @ 10:36
Comment from: Colin D.
I am a 19th Century orphan boy who has somehow ended up living in modern day Shanklin. I spend all my waking hours working my hands to the bone in the local workhouse. Alas, gruel is all I get to eat there, and only single portions, Mr. Crumble insists on that.
So, on that basis I feel you should pick me, I could feast on a funghi (pizza), gnaw on the gnocchi, ravish the ravioli or terrify a tiramisu.
A weekly Italian feast would surely supplement my 'gruel only' diet, no more would I have to plead, "Please Sir, can I have some more?....". Never again would I feel faint whilst climbing and cleaning chimneys, never again would I stare longingly at unfortunate rabbits lying squashed by the side of the road thinking how appetising they look....
You could really make a difference, so when making your choice please think of that 19th century orphan boy living in your midst and squashing his face against your window admiring the dishes you serve.........
Do I win??
So, on that basis I feel you should pick me, I could feast on a funghi (pizza), gnaw on the gnocchi, ravish the ravioli or terrify a tiramisu.
A weekly Italian feast would surely supplement my 'gruel only' diet, no more would I have to plead, "Please Sir, can I have some more?....". Never again would I feel faint whilst climbing and cleaning chimneys, never again would I stare longingly at unfortunate rabbits lying squashed by the side of the road thinking how appetising they look....
You could really make a difference, so when making your choice please think of that 19th century orphan boy living in your midst and squashing his face against your window admiring the dishes you serve.........
Do I win??
29/09/11 @ 19:58
Comment from: trevor and donna
We feel like another meal or 52, so enter us in the competition please
29/09/11 @ 20:21
Comment from: fletchy
great grub and a great vibe,
since day one ive been by your side.
tell all my mates that your the best,
in 20 years ive tried the rest.
without fail you fit us in,
even when weve not booked in.
like to say thankyou for serving us well,
and in your new venture we hope you do well.
52 meals would be good for me!
but im a paying customer as you can see!
either way well be back again and again
to the mamma mia gang.... my friends!
since day one ive been by your side.
tell all my mates that your the best,
in 20 years ive tried the rest.
without fail you fit us in,
even when weve not booked in.
like to say thankyou for serving us well,
and in your new venture we hope you do well.
52 meals would be good for me!
but im a paying customer as you can see!
either way well be back again and again
to the mamma mia gang.... my friends!
30/09/11 @ 12:47
Comment from: Mammamia
big opening day 31 dicember new mamma mia 55 high street 120 bottle champagne from the house to celebrate new years........new re4staurant.............old and new genuine custmers////and finaly you can remove the picture from this page afther tree years of bad advertaise ..
04/12/11 @ 09:42
Comment from: Graeme Egerton
This is brilliant. I've been laughing my head off all the way down this page, trying not to wake up Egerton jr. I'm gonna have to try this place to see just how good/bad it really is. I can't wait, frankly.
Matt & Cat respond: please do Graeme. We'd love to hear what you think. And don't forget to tell them we sent you, eh? ;)
Matt & Cat respond: please do Graeme. We'd love to hear what you think. And don't forget to tell them we sent you, eh? ;)
08/12/11 @ 23:08
Comment from: Keith
Couldn't agree more Graeme! Absolutely hilarious. There were moments when it resembled dialogue out-takes from Fawlty Towers.
11/12/11 @ 09:04
Comment from: chris price
I look through this website regularly and check out the comments on places that i often like to eat out in and mamma mia's is one of them. What i dont understand is along with some really good reviews and the few bad ones why all the negativity and sarcasm from some people and including you guys matt and catt. Is there a personal problem between you guys? Ive lived in shanklin for 19 years and can remeber these guys from as early on as when they had their first place at five ways. What i can say though is they have a good strong following , regular clientel and are always packed even in winter which is more then i can say for some of the places around.
I dont know if there have been falling outs between you guys or something but to be honest alot of people need to grow up and focusing on your own business and cut the sarcasm but thats just my opinion!
I dont know if there have been falling outs between you guys or something but to be honest alot of people need to grow up and focusing on your own business and cut the sarcasm but thats just my opinion!
11/12/11 @ 16:00
Comment from: mauro
tank chris this is the reality.....this sarcasm made from mat and cat is a compliment to me and soon the must stop because the new place non reflect the old so the got remove this page ...ps mat and cat wee haqve in alf custmers not sent others that is not be sarcastic
12/12/11 @ 14:41
Comment from: Mammamia
we have moved premises , remove us from this please as we have moved and this is no longer relevant to our premises
26/12/11 @ 17:00
Thanks for letting us know, Mamma Mia. And we wish you all the very best of luck with the new venue. We've marked the review as archive and closed comments, in line with our normal practice for closed venues.
27/12/11 @ 13:09
Comment feed for this postComments are closed for this post.
Recent comments