Seaview Hotel, Seaview
This 2008 review is of the Pump Bar. As the restaurant is quite different there is a separate review for that, which was written in 2010. All comments on this venue should now go on the new review.

Many mysterious things go on behind closed doors. For example, the election of a new pope is a particularly secretive procedure as cardinals assemble in Rome during the interregnum, taking an elaborate oath of secrecy and whispering amongst themselves in their conclave.
Away from the election of a new pontiff, behind more domestic doors, people are knitting alimentary canals, tormenting bees or selling virtual real estate in Second Life.
Wandering through the seemingly deserted streets of Seaview one Monday in January, Matt and Cat concluded that the population of this pretty village must have cleared orf for the winter, only to return in time for August's yachting regatta. But, shining out from the surrounding blank-eyed darkness of the High Street properties were the welcoming lights of the Seaview Hotel. Wasting no time, M and C entered the salubrious premises and were welcomed into the front bar area (the post-Christmas finances being too squeezed for the restaurant's tempting but pricier a la carte menu).
Review continues:

The bar was empty, save from your dining duo and the barman; who politely processed his solitary visitors. Whilst the drinks were poured Cat declared her hands to be jolly cold. At this point, the barman's manner changed ever so slightly as he offered Matt and Cat the chance to thaw out at the real fire in The Other Bar...
Having stayed one night at the Seaview Hotel back in 2004, M and C were familiar with the dining room, the front bar and even the upstairs lounge. However, behind closed doors at the back of the Seaview Hotel is a charming bar which, on the night Matt and Cat entered it, was thronging with chatting locals and warmed with a crackling log fire. Well, well, well...
Taking a seat on a banquette, which was upholstered in the most threadbare of nautically-themed tapestry, your reviewers glanced around the room. Sepia photographs of ships, sailors and piscators vied for wall-space with old oars, ropes and other boating debris. So far, so Spyglass. Warming herself by the cosy fire, Cat examined one of the photos which was of a group of Seaview fishermen taken in the 1880s. In a laboured calligraphic style the caption offered the fishermens' names, which included the spectacularly improbable Hexillexxon Howe and Nugent Caws. Other pictures were of local children splashing about at the regatta, and ginger-whiskered hero Peter Evans who appeared to have thwarted an invasion by Russians! Unlike other instant nautical memorabilia theme pubs, the items in the Seaview Hotel's Pump Bar had genuinely local provenance, offering a great deal of history and satisfying continuity.

Tearing their eyes from the decor, Matt and Cat turned their attention to the bar menu. As expected of a seafront establishment, there was a good selection of seafood including fish and mussel stew. Also tempting was the slow-cooked lamb shank, wild mushroom and spinach tart and Mr Gardener's venison sausages. As Cat had unclasped her purse, Matt took advantage and chose the rib-eye steak with roast tomatoes, field mushroom, chips and garlic and herb butter - the menu's most expensive offering. Cat balanced this expenditure by ordering sausage baguette with honey and mustard dressing, served with salad and chips.
To while away the wait for food, Matt and Cat visited the remarkably luxurious 'facilities'; in contrast to the homely Pump Bar, the rest of the hotel is furnished in a pleasant modern style. If a visitor was keen to take home a voguish item, there are some contemporary ceramics and jewellery for sale, displayed in glass cabinets near the toilets. Those with more... ahem... style than sense, could be the proud owner of a Fredrikson Stallard solid oak bird box with a cast aluminium twig for a perch - a snip at £80. Your tits will thank you.

Finding so many things to distract them from the task in hand, Matt and Cat nearly forgot to eat. Cat was pleased with her parsimonious alternative to Mr Gardener's sausage and mash (£12.95) for, at half the price, she enjoyed a brace of very tasty sausages drizzled with a sweet honey and mustard dressing, accompanied by a bowl of chunky chips and some dressed fresh foliage.
Matt's steak looked pleasing, tasted good and was cooked rare, as required. A freshly-cooked mushroom perched cheekily on top, and a knob of garlic butter complemented the meat very well; a nice touch.
So, having been invited into the Seaview Hotel's inner sanctum, Matt and Cat can declare the village open for business during the off-peak months. Good food in a delightfully authentic bar served by attentive staff will certainly chase those winter blues away (although it won't do much for the post-Christmas waistline!).
Tweet
Visit the website: http://www.seaviewhotel.co.uk/
4831 views
Categories: We like, Pub Grub, Ryde, Bembridge and St Helens, Hotels
12 comments
Apparently the hotel now takes all the current output of the farm. It also gets fresh fish from the splendid Captain Stan in Bembridge. This emphasis on local ingredients now takes pride of place, unlike the situation a couple of years ago when the then chef (very much a product of the Gordon Ramsey school judging by the sounds that used to emanate from the kitchen) was aspiring for a Michelin star with fussy and over-complicated dishes.
Nice warm scone, tasty jam and thick cream!
When you're good, you're very, very good...
Atmosphere: The decor was awful. Imagine a cheap eighties look and you're there. The plants were half dead. The walls were actually large mirrors at one end (dirty and smudged). The carpet was brown and dirty (along with my side plate). Don't get me started on the wall pictures (personal taste has nothing to do with it)!
Marks out of ten: 1 (we might as well have eaten in a shed)
Service: This is where every restaurant has the chance to redeem itself. The service was poor. There is no other way to describe having to ask for a steak knife and forgetting my dessert. I can now see why the manager (who served us all evening!) didn't let me taste the wine before filling my glass. The score here reflects the lack of apology for forgetting part of my meal.
Marks out of ten: 3 (too generous?)
Price: I like to think I understand the concept of value. What five pounds means to me is very different from what five pounds means to an African child from a rural village. We paid ninety pounds for the evening (two people). This is three times more than I wanted to pay for this particular experience. Go out in London (which I do) and even there that sort of money gets you a much more valued dining experience.
Marks out of ten: 2
Food: Good food! Yes, it's true the food was great. The steak was cooked perfectly and the daily special was lovely. Presentation of food was nice. Unfortunately it won't redeem the review as there are certainly other places on the island that have food just as good but provide so much more in terms of the other areas I have covered.
Marks out of ten: 8 (not the best but certainly very good)
Overall score: 14 / 40
Don't waste your time. I get the impression the restaurant manager feels the same.
First of all, let me sincerely apologise on behalf of the Seaview Hotel for the bad experience you have had with us recently.
We pride ourselves on our excellent customer service and attention to detail, and can only apologise that we were not up to our usual standards on this occasion. Forgetting your dessert and most importantly the lack of apology is inexcusable; we are grateful for your comments and will ensure that this does not happen again.
With regards to comments about our décor, we are as you know a Victorian hotel that is full of local history and it is very important to us that we don’t lose touch with this. The majority of our guests are people who have been coming here for years and love the fact that we haven’t changed our style to fit modern times and have maintained our traditions, which is what we are so well known for and has enabled our success for so many years. We have had many opportunities to modernise both our restaurants and bars but have declined because we would lose our large majority of guests, both visitors and villagers alike who regularly visit the hotel for who we are, a boutique hotel by the sea. We are proud to have a magnificent collection of naval pictures, photographs and artefacts – one of the most extensive private collections to be found on the Island.
We understand that this may not suit everyone’s tastes which is why we try to cater for all of our guests with a variety of dining options, the main restaurant, a smaller front restaurant, our lively naval pump bar, our front bar for more relaxed dining and a front terrace for those summer evenings when the sun shines.
We are very happy to hear that you enjoyed the food; we have recently changed direction with our dining serving classic British dishes using produce from our own farm including venison and Highland cattle. We source all of our food as locally as possible working closely with local farmers and fishermen to bring fresh, quality ingredients into our kitchen.
We hope that your experience is not enough to prevent you from returning to us, we would love the opportunity to get you back on side and if you would like to contact me personally by email to andrewmorgan@seaviewhotel.co.uk I will ensure that you are suitably spoilt.
My best wishes,
Andrew
Comments are closed for this post.



Recent comments