Crown Inn, Shorwell

Crown Inn, Shorwell photograph (c) scentnoodle

"Surely there can't be anywhere left that you haven't eaten?" is a question regularly asked of Matt and Cat. And, the geographically-minded of readers may have noticed that, within a five mile radius of Ryde, the choices are becoming fewer as more eateries are crossed off the list. Hence the recent excursions to Bembridge, Nettlestone and Sandown.

One dark evening, in the search for somewhere new, Matt and Cat pointed the Catmobile in a westerly direction and decided not to stop until a new place emerged in the glare of the headlamps. That place turned out to be the Crown Inn, Shorwell; the journey saw Matt and Cat waving as they passed already visited establishments in Ryde, Binstead, Wootton Bridge and Newport. What a lot of eating out!

Drawing the iron horse to a whinnying halt in the capacious pub car park, M and C entered the cosy pub. With its low ceilings and intimate lighting and nooks, The Crown, Shorwell retains an olde worlde pub feel. However, this doesn't mean that the pub is stuck in the dark ages; a lovely garden with weeping willows offers a stream-side al fresco dining experience to the gentle quacking of the resident ducks.

Review continues:

On a drizzly evening like the one when Matt and Cat visited, unless you are a determined smoker, you might be more comfortable inside the pub. On entering, they patrolled the entire venue and, because the place is arranged around a central bar, ended back where they started from and chose a table by the door.

Pork steak
Pork steak

In a cunning marketing move, the first thing that you see when you enter the pub is the specials board and M and C made their choices from the tempting array. However, in the interests of good manners and their readers, M and C took some time to see what was on offer in the regular menu before ordering chicken supreme with rosemary, lemon and white wine sauce, and pork steak with apple and cider sauce. Other delights included duck breast, plenty of seafood dishes, pub favourites, such as burgers, steaks and pasta; the day's vegetarian special was three bean and vegetable chilli with rice.

Chicken supreme
Chicken supreme

At first glance, the pork and chicken dinners looked pretty similar, with their creamy sauces, pale meats and tomato and parsley garnish. Their tastes were quite different though. The pork was delightfully lean and the sauce was sublime; the apple was neither too sweet nor too bitter and the cider gave it a great tang. Both meals were accompanied by chunky chips and one plate of seasonal vegetables to share.

The well-presented chicken supreme turned out to be both breasts of a roasted chicken, the skin of which had been seasoned to make it nice and crunchy, not flabby as chicken skin can sometimes be. The rosemary sauce was an interesting variation on chicken supreme's usual coriander, and was soon mopped up by the thick-cut chips.

As usual, Matt and Cat were unable to squeeze in a pudding, although the strawberry pavlova looked very tempting. Where do they get strawberries from this time of year? And where was the duck sourced from? On their exit from the pub, Matt and Cat noticed that the stream seemed strangely quackless...

PermalinkPublished: 18th October 2007
5392 views
Categories: We like, Pub Grub, Family friendly, Newport

27 comments

Comment from: Jef
Thought we'd give the Crown Inn a try after reading that it had won the Country Pub of the Year' award.
Nice Pub, Lovely Garden and the young lad behind the bar was very good and made us feel welcome, not so impressed by the woman serving the meals though, very scruffy and 'loud'.
The food was OK but nothing special, nice home made lamb burgers but spoilt by a cheap burger bun and re-fryed chips.
Overall a pleasant lunch but 'Pub of the Year'? wouldn't be my choice.
29/01/08 @ 14:01
Comment from: wendy

Apparently the Crown is under new management since I last visited, and it shows. We turned up at 6pm, wanting to get our food order in smartly because we had our young son with us. The pub was dark. At a few minutes past 6 a van pulled up, and a middle-aged couple emerged to open up.

We explained to our son what "amateurism" meant, and decided to hoof it to the Wight Mouse in Chale.

It was a chilly night so we took seats by the cosy fireplace, except it wasn't cosy because there was no fire, and no-one came to light it. We bought drinks and I could hear a flurry of activity at the bar, as it dawned on them that there was no-one in the kitchen. Much confusion as they frantically tried to locate their staff. People arrived who had booked tables, but were told that food orders would “probably” be taken at 6.30. This was not what we'd expected from the Crown, and the chances of having a hearty meal and still being home in time for our son's bedtime looked slim.

At 6.15, two young men flew in through the door, leaving it open behind them, so letting in wintry blasts, and dashed to the kitchen. We explained to our son what "amateurism" meant, and decided to hoof it to the Wight Mouse in Chale. And I'm very glad we did: warm and cosy, friendly service, very good nosh, and we still got home for my son's bedtime.

10/03/08 @ 05:18
Comment from: Mike and Gill Gregory
What a disappointment! Have been visiting the Crown over a number of years and been very pleased with the food. On our recent visit the food had really gone down hill. The homemade burger was tasteless and the Chicken burger was basically a piece of grilled chicken with no flavour and wrapped in a very soggy cheap bun. Chips were also hard! Feel very sorry for the new management but you haven't lived up to the last owners. Won't be going back.
24/03/08 @ 16:38
Comment from: Andrew Smith Email
Have not visited pub for a while but tonight my wife and I had an unexpected bad food experience.

The chicken supreme was two bits of tough chicken with RAGU poured on and the battered cod was not freshly battered just something nasty preprepared out of the fridge which was then over fried to a tough gritty dark brown.

I made my views clear to a bar attendant. However I was able to complement him on the excellent special beer.

We live on the Island.
06/05/08 @ 21:20
Comment from: Les Tergit
It's a shame reading the poor comments above, I actually had a very good meal here.

The Lamb Hot Pot was very tasty and the vegetables fresh and not over-cooked.

My infinitely better half had a PROPER steak and ale pie, not a steak casserole in a pot with puff pastry dumped on top. How many pubs nowadays do proper pies?

One negative comment, please do away with the 2 seater table next to the Gents toilets. Besides it being an unfortunate place to be seated it is also a nightmare to negotiate when you are busting for one!!
27/05/08 @ 20:08
Comment from: Geoff
Had Sunday lunch on 8th June, but would not have done if I had read the earlier comments!

We had parsnip and honey soup (good) followed by roast beef which was very good. Giant quantities, no wonder there is an obesity problem, so no room for pudding. We only ordered the soup because there was a notice on the bar stating there was a 45 minute delay for main courses, but fortunately we were were in no hurry.

Vegetables were fair, but I don't see how it won the Country Pub award. Maybe they have lots of friends voting for them.Also I didn't like the fact that you order drinks in one place and food in another - I can't be faffing about.
10/06/08 @ 21:46
Comment from: Nick Clark
5 of us ate there on 28th June, a busy night but we had booked. We waited ages for the starter. We asked where was the crab starter and a young waiter apologised and said that he had taken it to another table by mistake. When it came it was good. However when the mains came they had obviously been waiting under the heat somewhere. My bass fillets were dried up. They should have gone back but it was now getting so late we could not wait still longer. On paying I pointed this out to the land lady? who said she was sorry, it should not have happened, I should have sent the food back...... and continued to charge me the full bill. We'll give the Crown a miss in future.
12/07/08 @ 18:26
Comment from: John Turner
I had the unfortunate opertunity to visit the crown inn on the evning of the 21st of june.
I will definitely not be going back and would not recomend it to anyone.
I was very dissapointed in that most of the menu that was on the table was unavailable and when we did find a dish that they actually had i had to wait an hour and 45 mins to get it shorly a chicken burger and trout fillets which when we got them they were over cooked and very bland can not take that long to cook. When i tried to complain about my meal i could not even find a senior member of staff, apparantly they were having a drink in the bar which i find incredibly lazy as it was aparant that the staff working were rushed off there feet. I will definitely not be going back and would not recomend it to anyone. Since that night i have learned that there was no chef and that untrained staff were having to deal with a very busy night,most unprofessional!
24/07/08 @ 23:06
Comment from: George
As a member of staff at The Crown Inn, Shorwell i would just like to say that from the dates given on the comments above i can say that we were having difficult second chef problems and the head chef had to have time off due to a new baby so supposedly "excellent" chefs were hired through an agency. But after a week or so it came to the attention that the chefs were awful - they were soon fired! I can now assure you that the head chef is back and has a new fresh team to work with. The food is extremely local and fresh where possible. Crab is caught and prepared and at the crown in the space of 4hours. The steaks & beef is reared from the local farm in shorwell, some deserts (pavolova's and cheesecakes) are made from a b & B owner, and i must say they are very tasty (mars bar cheesecake and white chocolate cheesecake) The produce used to make the food is fresh and local.

The bar now has a new female manager that is warm and welcoming, the kitchen has a fantastic young enthusiastic team that work smoothly and efficiently.
05/09/08 @ 23:32
Comment from: anonymous
As a previous employee of the The Crown Inn, i feel the above comment is far from truthful. The responsibility lies on the owners of the food being produced and staffing issues being no other than their responsibility and i particularly feel they have far from there staff interests in mind, going on holiday for the week of having no chef being a key example. I feel it is sad that such a wonderful place to work has been lost hence why i no longer work there. From what i have heard of the new bar manager she has upset regular customers already, far from welcoming in my opinion. Its a shame to see mike and sallys hard work of twenty five years thrown away in less than a year. Some people just aren't cut to run a pub clearly.
16/09/08 @ 12:49
Comment from: George
In reply to above comment: I feel that the owners do have the staff interests in mind. As for their holiday, they were already on holiday when the bar manager decided to leave along side chefs, therefore, the owners only new about the departure of these staff whilst they were on holiday meaning they didnt go away knowing that didnt have a chef. How long ago did you leave as stories get a bit mixed when they get relayed, as the truth behind the new manager upsetting a local is ridiculous!!! The truth is that people were already sat at their table and the locals became childish and upset that someone was sat on their table. The locals hadnt booked whereas the people sitting on the table had. it is quite funny how things get twisted!.

I have to agree with you on one thing tho. The crown inn is a wonderful place!

However, mike and sallys hard work has definitly not be thrown away, but has been built upon and the new owners hard work is paying off.

Its funny because you dont work their so your know just making judgments about things you hear.

Some people arn't cut out to work at a pub ( i guess thats why you dont work there anymore).
17/09/08 @ 14:46
Comment from: Wendy
Pleased to say our visit to The Crown today was far better than last time (see my comment from March 08). The opening hours (12-9pm each day), menu, and staffing have all improved, attitude was generally cheery and helpful. We were able to place our order promptly and food arrived within half an hour. Ian enjoyed his pork steak on apple sauce, with a cheese topping. My tuna steak was plentiful, though I was a bit thrown by the orange and mango "compote" accompanying it, which contained tinned mandarin oranges; not quite the zingy sauce I'd anticipated. Accompanying vegetables were very nicely done: cabbage, carrots and creamed swede with pepper; plus new potatoes. My six-year old son wolfed down a tuna mayo sandwich, served with crisps and salad.

The Crown was busy (Sunday evening), with plenty of booked tables. I do hope the teething problems for the new management are over and it continues to improve.
28/09/08 @ 22:47
Comment from: John
I hear that the head chef is up for an award.
06/11/08 @ 18:30
Comment from: Colin and Teresa
Visited The Crown Tuesday 18th November having previously had many good meals there. However, it was very disapponting. The vegetable curry was in fact carrot curry and not very tasty. The chicken curry was completely tasteless - bits of what appeared to be frozen chicken in a tomato sauce. The plaice was very dry with a very thick coating. We did complain at the time and were offered free puds or coffee but declined. We will not be back.
20/11/08 @ 14:18
Comment from: Paul
It's a shame to see the negetive comments above. My wife and I regularly eat out and
consider the crown to be one of the best pubs on the island.
We popped in today and the food was as excellent as ever; had the portebella steak after
much deliberation!(lots of specials to chose from!) she had the mushroom stroganoff

the young barman was very welcoming and friendly and it was nice to cosy up next to
the crackling fire!

We were told about an upcoming dickens 'christmas carol' night in decmber complete with
turkey and pudding so have already booked ourselves in!

Highly Recommended to anyone!
22/11/08 @ 20:29
Comment from: Kate
Visited the Crown recently after a long absence and have to say we enjoyed ourselves immensely!
The food was great and the service was even better, Staff were very friendly and we had many a giggle so thank you to pauline and gareth! will be back


13/01/09 @ 00:58
Comment from: VANESSA GOODALL Email
from Vanessa.
Myself and my husband went for a meal at the Crown on Sunday evening and it was extremely good!!
After reading some of the reviews we were a tad apprehensive? but the meals were perfect, my husband always has steak and the sirloin he said was cooked to perfection!
All in all we had a perfect evening of good food, good company and excellent customer service the barman was first class!!!
Would recommend to all.
18/02/09 @ 10:30
Comment from: Geoff
Having not been to the Crown for many years, probably 10 or more, we decided to see what it is like these days.

Choice of beers pretty good. Nice atmosphere but a bit noisy.

We ordered 2 chicken curries, scampi and pasta dish. the pasta and scampi were OK but the curries !!

8 chunks of chicken on a bed of rice covered in a chili tomato sauce - definately NOT curry.

when we went to pay i mentioned that the 'curry' was disappointing and was asked "what not enough chicken"

I think I might try again in another 10 years.

PS the meals were also on the expensive side
10/05/09 @ 20:00
Comment from: A former overner

The Crown has been one of our favourite places to eat on the Island for years and when we
lived on the Island for a while, we went there regularly. However, on a trip there last
summer, we were VERY disappointed with the food. As it was quite a cold day (don't you
just love our English weather!) we ordered some good old pub food - sausage and mash
with homemade onion gravy. I can honestly say it was the worst food I have ever
had. The sausage and mash were barely warm and the sausage was undercooked but the most
unappetising part of it was the gravy. Instead of homemade onion gravy as promised - a
pot of the cheapest catering-type oxtail soup seemed to have been poured over it! It
really was awful. We should have complained, but didn't. Instead we both spent the rest
of the day feeling very ill.

We're coming over to the Island again soon and really hope that the chef problems at The
Crown have been sorted out now as it used to be a lovely place to eat and spend an hour
or so sitting in the pub garden.

09/06/09 @ 11:30
Comment from: brinkley
The place to go to be screwed over. And when you challenge they tell you you're lying!
For all the prettiness of the location, going to The Crown spoilt what would otherwise have been a lovely day.
13/08/09 @ 10:10
Comment from: Reeny
The Crown used to be a favourite of ours for food years ago, when they used to do the best garlic bread on the island! We visited last year and sadly said we were sure we'd never bother again as it was not the same quality as it used to be.

We must be forgiving souls as we went again a few days ago and sat out in the lovely garden. One of us had the home made burger and the other had the tagliatelle. Wow! We were both impressed with the quality of the freshly made food that was served by a friendly waitress. Portions were generous and I have never before tasted such a lovely balsamic dressing as I did on my side salad, that came with the burger. The husband normally wont go near a mushroom, so I was expecting to see a little pile of them left on his plate. But no, he actually enjoyed them.

The Crown is back on my pub list!
28/09/09 @ 21:42
Comment from: Previous employee
Firstly may I say that I worked at the Crown Inn Shorwell on the dates when the above postings by 'George' were written and there was no guy called George working there!! I'm pretty sure that said postings are by the new owners pretending to be a contented staff member, as believe me there aren't actually any.

The Crown is a beautiful pub with a good head chef, who is completely over-worked and undervalued, when the owners unfairly sacked the second chef said head chef actually had to work seven days a week, all day. No wonder the food and time taken to serve it often suffers, as demonstrated by the majority of the comments on here. As for the owners, the landlady in particular, is a nasty piece of work, who completely disrespects and intimidates her staff and has no idea of how to correctly treat people. I only put up with it for so long as attempts to find an alternative job were slow in the midst of a recession. I frequently saw her being rude and arrogant to customers, I could write a list of times that she was so rude to customers that they walked out! I witnessed her cause one couple to leave after accusing their children of being 'incapable of manners and dirty' when they accidently spilt some food on the floor. I was gobsmacked and very embarrassed that I worked for her.

Basically I could go on and on but I won't! All I can say is, as a previous person has posted, it is a huge shame that the Crown Inn has fallen into the hands of a couple who dont deserve it. I worked with some fantastic, hard-working people while I was there, the vast majority of staff are excellent and without them the place would fall apart, a shame the owners dont appreciate them.

Also, a final point, if you do go to the Crown and if you feel obliged to tip, I would make a point of asking that the tips actually get into the hands of the staff that they are intended for...
16/12/09 @ 18:25
Comment from: Anonymous
I would not recommend this place even with the new menu & a big change they should have done is to have reduced the prices... It's a pub not a restaurant.
It is such a shame as the actual pub & grounds are spectacular & gorgeous in the summer.
As another person has mentioned "staff are excellent and without them the place would fall apart" & the landlords should quit before things get any worse, if thats possible & let people take over who know what they are doing!!

OVERALL - DON'T GO
25/03/10 @ 21:40
Comment from: David D. Ballard Email
Very friendly service. Generous portions... and suitably hot. Great puds. Special mention of the Spotted Dick. I've not had that for years (medical joke!)
11/04/10 @ 22:35
Comment from: Jon
Seems all is not well at the Crown! Zero stars on the EHO website!!!!
21/05/10 @ 23:05
Comment from: John Murrell
At the weekend I took a party of 14 people for a Saturday lunch.
We had a copy of the latest menue from Pamela so we Knew in advance what was available, so ordering did not take too long.
Because it was a large group and we had warned them in advance we had a special table in one of the side rooms set for us.
We all thought that the choice of food was excellent and the service very good. There was no complaints and everybody was well satisfied with their food. One of our party had the duck and is going back to have the other half!
The Crown is a beautiful pub in a nice setting with a large garden and a river flowing through filled with trout.
A realy nice place and I would not hesitate to go back again.
21/06/10 @ 21:11
Comment from: John C
Having been a regular visitor to the Crown when Mike and Sally were mine hosts and disappointed when they retired it was sad to find lower standards in all departments under the new managment. After two very poor meals we decided to cease visiting. Nearly two years later we had another try recently. It was even worse - cottage pie a liquid mess swimming with peas, tastless burgers with no seasoning, unfriendly staff and worst of all the lovely garden was totally unkept not a flower in sight and scruffy. We shall not go again. I would be surprised if the owners survive next winter !
13/07/10 @ 13:28

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.
But if you use a phony email your comment may be deleted.
Yes, we do sometimes check.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
What colour is an orange? (Don't use any capital letters in your answer)
antispam test